"Хоббит-1": Рецензии, отзывы в СМИ

[48 FPS]

Сообщение от Mr.Aufiderzein

Похоже ворнеры пытаются лихорадочно спасти проэкт,

Сообщение от Mr.Aufiderzein

Обычно на фильмы эмбарго не вешают

Сообщение от Mr.Aufiderzein

Эмбарго очень сильно влияет на мнение зрителей

Сообщение от Mr.Aufiderzein

если вы разбираетесь в бокс офисах то вам должно быть это понятно

Ей-Богу кто вам внушил эдакую ахинею, это же явно слова вырванные из контекста.

Сообщение от watashikun

меньше общайтесь с админом КиноНьюса.

Это который, часом не Эндрю?

[Mr.Aufiderzein]

Я оффтопить больше не собираюсь, если есть вопросы Mr Aufiderzein 8)

[Gash]

Новый положительный отзыв с твиттера https://twitter.com/JoeCorrell

@TheHobbitMovie the movie was fantastic!
Congrats to all! Amazing!

[Bofur]

Я даже не буду пытаться сохранить хладнокровие. Не хочу себя настраивать негативно. Я знаю ВК и знаю, что от Джексона можно всего ожидать. Его не упрекнёшь в том, что не любит Толкина. Поэтому приятно читать положительные отзывы, а на отрицательные не реагирую. Если кто-либо напишет 100% отрицательное ревью, для меня такой человек будет одним из тех, чьи уголки души ничего не затрагивает. Вот так Я ждал фильм слишком долго, чтобы отрицательно критиковать сюжетные элементы. Технические еще можно обсудить.

[Павел]

Сообщение от Mr.Aufiderzein

Я оффтопить больше не собираюсь, если есть вопросы Mr Aufiderzein 8)

Спасибо за ссылку. Многое объясняет.

[Mr.Aufiderzein]

Сообщение от Павел

Спасибо за ссылку. Многое объясняет.

Что именно, если не секрет

[Павел]

Секрет. И оффтоп.

[Mr.Aufiderzein]

Сообщение от Павел

Секрет. И оффтоп.

Ну тогда смысла в ваших сообщения - 0.

[Mr.Aufiderzein]

Сообщение от watashikun

Он самый. Настоящий тролль.

Andrew помешан на Скайффоле, и заранее настроил все свои новости против Хоббита

[Павел]

Сообщение от Mr.Aufiderzein

Andrew помешан на Скайффоле, и заранее настроил все свои новости против Хоббита

Какая связь?

[Mr.Aufiderzein]

Сообщение от Павел

Какая связь?

Есть связь.

[Павел]

Эх, вот бы эмбарго продлили до 19-го декабря:-)

[Маг]

Так никто же спойлеры читать не заставляет)))

[48 FPS]

На BFCA упал до 80/100

[Mrs.Underhill]

Peter Jackson has a total b**** for Thorin.

Питер Джексон мыслит в правильном направлении, я с ним солидарна.

[Gash]

Наконец то полноценная рецензия! Which Way Is Awesome?: The Hobbit - A Review

MY RATING: 10

Running Time: 166 mins

Directed by Peter Jackson

Starring Martin Freeman, Ian McKellen, Richard Armitage and Andy Serkis


I can hear the chorus of doubters now:

"The Hobbit is too short of a book to be stretched into 2 movies, let alone 3!"

"It's lightweight kids stuff! Nothing like The Lord Of The Rings."

"Peter Jackson is a hack now who can't direct a good movie anymore. Have you seen The Lovely Bones?"

Consider the chorus silenced! The team of Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh and Phillipa Boyens (with an assist from Guillermo Del Toro) have brought us seamlessly back into the Tolkien universe with the first of 3 "Hobbit" films. It's honestly a miracle they were able to pull it off. Some of those criticisms are entirely justified. The novel "The Hobbit" is indeed a short tale that is much lighter in tone than "Lord Of The Rings". And while the merits of any director's work are always a subjective matter, I certainly can't argue with anyone when they say that both "King Kong" and "The Lovely Bones" were a step down from the "Rings" trilogy. However, once this movie gets going all worries are thrown aside. The team has managed to wring so much drama and suspense out of the very small piece of literature they are adapting, largely because they do precisely what movies aren't supposed to do as well as books. By stretching out the book, they are able to go into detail about things that are merely glanced over in the text, creating a more fully realized universe than the source material. Battles mentioned as anecdotes in the text are breathtakingly brought to life in full detail, and some seemingly minor predicaments in the speedy story of the Tolkien book are given import simply by allowing each to have its moment.

This is a movie about storytelling, first and foremost. We are introduced to Bilbo Baggins as an old man, writing down his account of the events that are about to transpire, so that Frodo can finally know the story of his life. As the film progresses, many legends are told and some new ones are born. We witness the dragon attack on the Dwarf Kingdom of Erebor. We are shown an epic battle between dwarves and orcs that sows the seed of resentment in the heart of the dwarf leader Thorin (Armitage) and his sworn enemy the Pale Orc. Though all of this is merely prelude to the story at hand, it is crucial for allowing the events to have the proper weight. Rather than simply following the quest Bilbo (Freeman) must go on with the dwarves and Gandalf The Grey (McKellen), these ripping good yarns allow us to understand exactly what's at stake.

Martin Freeman turned out to be a fantastic addition to the universe, in spite of the doubters' claims that he was too "ironic" for the material (there they go again). There is a clear distinction drawn between Bilbo and Frodo as protagonists which stems from Bilbo's legacy. He is torn between his simple, unassuming Baggins side and his thrill-seeking, more assertive Took side. This allows Freeman some freedom to contribute something new to the film series, and he delivers solidly. Ian McKellen is once again magnificent in arguably the most iconic role of his long career. And surprisingly he gets to kick more ass than usual. The impossibly spry old man (no doubt with the help of a few stand ins) does quite a bit of running, fighting and sword-wielding here, to the delight of us all. I won't spoil how Gollum figures into this tale, mainly because the sequence involving him is such a joy to watch play out, but I have to once again congratulate the great Andy Serkis for yet another insanely good motion capture performance. Anybody can put on the wetsuit with the silver balls all over it and allow computers to capture their movements. But nobody can imbue pure feeling and humanity into a CGI performance quite like Serkis can.

After all the headaches involved in getting this on the big screen, its certainly easy to enter into this new film with some amount of skepticism. But what has finally emerged is a towering epic on par with the first three films in the series; a masterclass in fantasy filmmaking with some of the best, most authentic genre setpieces filmed this year. Say what you will about Jackson as a director, but no one can deny that his style and sensibility is perfectly suited to this kind of movie. He allows us to believe, for a fleeting moment, in a world populated by giant eagles and tree people that coexist with wizards, demons and elves. The movie is imbued with the same spirit of fellowship and brotherhood, as well as the humor and gravitas, that marked both the Tolkien works and the first series of films. I'm so glad to have these movies back, and I'm even happier to report that this first one makes me feel like we never left.

SIDE NOTE: I saw the movie in the standard 24 frames per second rate and I plan to go back on opening night to see it in 48 FPS with some 3D glasses on to see how all the new technology affects my viewing experience. As for now I can't comment either way on those things. I can only say that as a film, without all the bells and whistles, it works perfectly.

[Gash]

Еще порция положительного твитта:

Jason T. Clark ‏@Jason_T_Clark
#Hobbit was fantastic!!! So happy to be back in
Middle-Earth. This is a must see. 48Fps is
interesting, but overall I didn't care for it.

Matthew P. Spill ‏@matthewspill
Hobbit was great! 48fps is weird. Neat but not
necessary. Can't wait for next December!

Joanclair Richter ‏@joanclairme
Hobbit screening - visually stunning. The beginning
of it all. Peter Jackson Q & A - what a mind!

Nicholas DeNitto ‏@NicksMovies
Just saw The Hobbit and was STUNNED. See this
movie in 3D at 48 FPS! It looks incredible!

[Entwife]

Сообщение от Mrs.Underhill

Питер Джексон мыслит в правильном направлении, я с ним солидарна.

А можно намекнуть хотя бы, в каком направлении мыслит автор слов "total b..."?

[sobocage]

Сообщение от Entwife

А можно намекнуть хотя бы, в каком направлении мыслит автор слов "total b..."?

Total badass. Крайне крут, короче.

[Entwife]

Спасибо. Правда, мне показалось, что у Торина будет ещё и немного более "человечный" характер, чем в книге. Но мне это даже больше нравится.

[Gash]

Во как

Eric Brown ‏@ TheEricBrown
Just saw The Hobbit . It moved faster and held my
attention better than any of the LOTR movies.

[Eldariel]

Что ж, новости, в принципе, хорошие. Единственное, что омрачает радость - навязчивая мысль: "Почему же, почему же так медленно тянется время??"

[Павел]

Неудержался, прочитал ревью. Оно просто шикарное. И спойлер по-сути один.

"The Pale Orc" это же Азог? Жив похоже все-таки, зараза.
 

[Gene]

Наверное, стоит скорее интересоваться мнением тех рецензентов, кому очень запала в душу прошлая трилогия. Иначе есть риск неправильно понять людей, которые таки дождались своего Джа-Джа-Бинкса Радагаста, ведь им так не хватало странных клоунов в ВК.

[Gash]

Говорят в фильм нет нескольких сцен из трейлеров - несколько сцен в начале фильма в шире и сцена Бильбо с Нарсилом, которая из первого трейлера.

[Gash]

Сообщение от Gene

Наверное, стоит скорее интересоваться мнением тех рецензентов, кому очень запала в душу прошлая трилогия. Иначе есть риск неправильно понять людей, которые таки дождались своего Джа-Джа-Бинкса Радагаста, ведь им так не хватало странных клоунов в ВК.

Попадалась пара отзывов, в которых говорится - если вы фанат ВК, то вы не разочаруетесь.

[Павел]

Сообщение от Gash

Говорят в фильм нет нескольких сцен из трейлеров - несколько сцен в начале фильма в шире и сцена Бильбо с Нарсилом, которая из первого трейлера.

Ну дык для режиссерской версии должно же было что-то остаться:-)

[Gash]

Пара настоящих отзызов с форума IMDb

. Saw a screening of the hobbit tonight in hollywood.
It was amazing! The best CGI i probably have ever
seen. If you are a die hard fan of the LOTR films
then you will not be let down. A fun ride, lots of
action and story, beautiful cinematography and
music.
No spoilers from me. Enjoy the film!

The friend I took is a bigger fan than me and he
said he liked them just as much or more than the
originals.
IMDb :: Boards :: Der Hobbit - Eine unerwartete Reise (2012) :: Saw a screening tonight!

I saw the film with the National Board of Review.
Due to their guidelines, I'm not allowed to publish
any official reviews until the film is released.
However, there's no rule against me just talking on
a message board.
Visually, the film is stunning, particularly in 3D 48
fps. Completely engrossing and hardly a dull
moment. There's a good amount of light hearted
humor, especially from the dwarves, so the tone
isn't too gloomy. The action sequences are
thrilling, particularly an opening sequence where
Smaug the dragon destroys a town. There's also a
stimulating, grand scale battle between a few stone
giants that the dwarves and hobbit literally get
caught between. The ending can feel a bit out of
the blue if you aren't familiar with the other films.
Overall though, an incredible experience.

I'll admit I was a bad critic and didn't rewatch the
original trilogy before seeing this one, so they
aren't fresh in my mind. As far I can remember, I
believe this was better than Fellowship and TT.
However, let it be known I didn't consider either of
those films to be particularly fantastic. They were
great, but they didn't capture me the way this one
did.
If you're a die hard fan, I highly doubt you'll be
disappointed in The Hobbit. The only way I can see
fans of LOTR being disappointed is if they are
expecting it to be as serious as the original trilogy.
The Hobbit has lots and lots of humor in it, to the
point where you can even argue it's making fun of
itself. But there are plenty of intense moments of
violent battle to balance it out.
My review will be published on
FestivalOfFilms.com the day The Hobbit is
released. I'd love to publish it earlier, but the
guidelines of the group I'm with do not allow for it.

IMDb :: Boards :: Der Hobbit - Eine unerwartete Reise (2012) :: SEE IT IN 3D 48 FPS!!!!

[TheHutt]

Сдержанная рецензия:

FLIP: Film Review: The Hobbit - an Unexpectedly Long Journey

И восторженная:

Which Way Is Awesome?: The Hobbit - A Review

[Mrs.Underhill]

Сообщение от Entwife

А можно намекнуть хотя бы, в каком направлении мыслит автор слов "total b..."?

На PG-13 это значит, что Питер Джексон, сильно, эээ... тащится от Торина. И правильно делает!

У Торина интересная и трагическая арка характера, и динамика с Бильбо. Если я буду тащиться от них двоих (а с этими актерами шансы велики), то прощу все остальное, и для меня фильм попадет в точку.